It says a lot about the dysfunctional Wyeth family, portrayed in John Robin Baitz’s Other Desert Cities,that the only truthful and nuanced character is a barely recovering alcoholic: Aunt Silda.
Silda (a similarly nuanced Deena Baltman), despite her struggles to resist alcohol, is the one family member who can look herself in the mirror and not profess to be something she isn’t. But she’s not the character who dominates this rousing Alumnae Theatre production of Other Desert Cities, the name derived from the green signs over California Interstate 10, directing drivers to Indio California and “other desert cities,” i.e., Palm Springs. The show closes Sunday, February 2. Catch it if you can.
It’s the Wyeth mother, Polly, who drives this play. As embodied by a dynamic and convincing Lynn Oldenshaw, she’s the centre of the action, even when she’s not on stage. Polly is the expert, an old guard “Hollywood Republican,” friend to Nancy Reagan, fundraiser, socialite, happily sitting on top of her Palm Springs, California world. She quickly establishes her point of view, railing at her daughter Brooke (Melody Schaal) who’s come from New York to spend Christmas with her parents and brother Trip (Bobby Markov), a reality tv showrunner.
Here’s Polly on east coast lefties: “It’s all vegans and meth addicts.” Her children, particularly Brooke, belong to the “entitled Me generation.”
Polly is a big problem for daughter Brooke, a New York magazine writer turned novelist and memoirist. She’s suffered a mental breakdown in the not too distant past, protests her mother’s biases, Polly utters the classic denial statement: “I haven’t got a bigoted bone in my body.”
Brooke, is equally set in her ways. She’s a large person, but proud of her vulnerabilities. A bit of a whiner, she harbours huge resentment against her domineering mother, who just happened to be the person who nursed her in the midst of mental breakdown. “Why couldn’t you back your daughter instead of that wet little . . .,” she says of one of Polly’s favourite causes.
Trip is a hyperactive, hypomaniacal, Los Angeleno in the thick of a career he might have landed in easily, given his parents’ long run as minor Hollywood actors. He is trying his best to play the peacemaker, the bridge between his sister and his parents Polly and Lyman, and not succeeding very well.
Rob Scavone as Lyman Wyeth tries to project the authoritative actor and TV commercial spokesman whom Ronald Reagan later appointed an ambassador. But he’s bland enough for the role of peacemaker, especially with Brooke, burying the memory of his dead son and being suspiciously evasive on what happened to Henry.
The story is that Henry was implicated in the bloody bombing of a US military recruitment centre by some urban terrorists. He disappeared for three weeks after the incident in which a person was killed. The authorities find his body and it bears a suicide note.
In the in the climax to Act 1, Brooke announces her “novel” is actually a memoir. The New Yorker is about to publish excerpts from it. Her real purpose in coming to sunny Palm Springs, a place she hates, is to ask her parents to read her manuscript before some of its contents appear a short time hence. She would like their consent to publish it.
The second half of Other Desert Cities contains the explosive denouement. But even before that revelation, the play has descended into histrionics, with Silda coming into her own as the mirror up to her sister’s and niece’s behaviour; Polly going on full attack, threatening to sue her own daughter if the New Yorker publishes her; and Brooke getting increasingly angry, digging in her heels about publishing. As for Trip, he goes postal in an unnecessary way on the subject of why no one takes him seriously as the showrunner of a TV series about the courts, the judges, the juries, and so on. Lyman’s true role in the events now under discussion is finally revealed.
The lighting on the set was rather weird and the set itself, although well designed, just sits there. Palm Springs was traditionally the playground of Hollywood actors and directors because it was close enough to LA that performers could drive there on breaks and be back in time for shooting. But no effort is made to recreate that ambience.
The play could have used a soundscape to shape the mood, especially given the musical heritage of Hollywood. Nevertheless, Other Desert Cities demands to be seen.
Other Desert Cities
Written by Jon Robin Baitz, directed by Ilana Linden and produced by Amélie Martyn and Melody Schaal.
At the Alumnae Theatre, until Sunday February 2, 2025
Photo by Amanda Matlovich: From left, Lyman, Polly, Trip, Brooke and Silda




